Bay Bakery

3.4(52)

16/330 Fishery Point Rd, Bonnells Bay, New South Wales, 2264

Call Now Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersTakeaway

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesCustom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Sausage rollsSandwichesTakeawayWheelchair accessibleCard & contactless payments

Why Choose Bay Bakery?

Bay Bakery is known locally for curry and pepper pies, alongside fresh cakes made daily, including custom orders for birthdays and other occasions. Takeaway and wheelchair access make it convenient, though trading hours can be tight, so it's worth checking before you visit.

About Bay Bakery

Bay Bakery is a neighbourhood bakery in Bonnells Bay, New South Wales, doing the sort of everyday baking people pop in for on the way past. Pies are the main draw, and the curry and pepper versions get a particular mention, alongside sausage rolls and sandwiches. Things come fresh from the oven, and the staff are described as friendly.

Custom cakes are a regular part of the trade too. One local ordered a birthday cake here for their son and found it fresh and fairly priced, and the bakery is recommended for cakes for all sorts of occasions. If you're after something sweet to take home, custard pies and slices are popular, and the lamingtons are sought after when they're on the shelf, though they aren't made every day.

Everything is set up for takeaway, so it suits a quick stop for lunch or a bag of something warm for the car. There's a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance, and card and mobile payments are listed, but one local says they've found the shop cash only, so it's wise to bring some cash just in case. The hours run seven days a week, with shorter days on weekends, and it's worth checking them before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Pastries

“Make sure you get the meat pies The curry and pepper versions are wonderfully delish.”

Cakes

“Beautiful birthday cake for my son's birthday. So fresh and reasonably priced.”

Staff

“Always super friendly service and great food. Their lamingtons are the best ever.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Bay Bakery? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bay Bakery

: Bay Bakery is best known for its pies, with the curry and pepper versions getting particular praise from locals. It also turns out sausage rolls, sandwiches, custard pies and slices, and custom cakes for birthdays and other occasions. Staff are generally described as friendly, and the baking is noted as fresh from the oven.
: Yes, custom cake orders are a regular part of the trade at Bay Bakery. One local ordered a birthday cake for their son and found it fresh and reasonably priced. The bakery is recommended for cakes for all sorts of occasions, so it's worth calling ahead to discuss what you need for your event.
: Bay Bakery accepts debit cards and NFC mobile payments. However, some visitors have found the bakery operates cash-only at times, so it's worth ringing ahead or bringing cash to be safe.
: Yes, Bay Bakery offers a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance, making it a straightforward stop whether you're using a wheelchair or just wheeling in a pram for a quick takeaway pie or sandwich on the way past.
: Opinions vary. Many locals rate the pies highly, especially the curry and pepper meat pies and the custard pies, and call out friendly service and fair prices. Others have found pies small for the price or pastry on the thin side, and service inconsistent. It's worth checking the hours before visiting, as a few customers have found it shut earlier than expected.