The Bakery Witch

5.0(44)

20 Excalibur Ave, Castle Hill, New South Wales, 2154

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersDeliveryTakeaway

Custom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

CupcakesBirthday cakeBanoffee pieTakeawayDelivery

Why Choose The Bakery Witch?

The Bakery Witch specialises in custom cakes that match your vision, with customers returning repeatedly for birthdays and celebrations. Cupcakes, brownies and the banoffee pie are standouts, and the team accommodates dietary requirements, including eggless options, without compromising on texture or flavour.

About The Bakery Witch

The Bakery Witch is a small Castle Hill bakery that has built its name on custom cakes, and the people who've used it tend to come back for the next birthday or family occasion. Locals mention cakes that match the picture they brought in, or turn out even better, with detailing to match the flavour.

Cupcakes are a particular favourite. We've heard they were a lifesaver for one family whose gender reveal plans fell through at the last minute, and that the buttercream is light and smooth and the sponge properly moist. Beyond cakes, there's a banoffee pie people rave about, plus brownies and cookies. Seasonal gift boxes, like the Mother's Day one, go down well with families.

Eggless baking is a real strength here. Cakes, cookies and brownies made without eggs are said to come out soft and rich, so you wouldn't guess anything was missing. People also say the bakery is accommodating with other dietary needs if you mention them when ordering.

Staff are friendly and the value is considered fair for the quality. Takeaway and delivery are both available, and you can pay by phone. Custom orders are best arranged ahead of time, so it's worth checking the hours and talking timing with the bakery before you plan a celebration around it.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Cakes

“The buttercream was so smooth and light and the cake itself was so moist.”

Pastries

“The Bakery Witch came to the rescue and absolutely exceeded our expectations with her cupcakes! The cupcakes were not only beautifully done, but they were also delicious and such a hit with everyone at the reveal.”

Cakes

“The cake was even better than the reference picture we shared while ordering the cake. The detailing was perfect. The taste was superb.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with The Bakery Witch? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Bakery Witch

: The Bakery Witch has built its reputation on custom cakes, with customers often returning for birthdays and family occasions. It's also well known for cupcakes with light, smooth buttercream and moist sponge, plus a banoffee pie with a good biscuit base, brownies and cookies, including eggless options on request.
: Yes, custom cake orders are a core service at The Bakery Witch in Castle Hill. Customers regularly share a reference picture and the team matches or improves on the design, with careful detailing and flavour. Owner Bushra is mentioned by name for understanding what customers want. It's wise to order ahead, especially for short-notice requests.
: Yes, The Bakery Witch accommodates dietary requests, with eggless cakes, cookies and brownies specifically mentioned as turning out soft and moist despite the substitution. It's best to mention any dietary needs when placing your order so the bakery can prepare accordingly.
: Yes, The Bakery Witch offers both delivery and takeaway, along with custom cake orders. The bakery also supports NFC mobile payments in store. For exact pricing on cakes, cupcakes or dessert boxes, it's best to contact the bakery directly.
: Yes, cupcakes and seasonal dessert boxes, such as the Mother's Day box with eggless choc chunk cookies and Nutella, Biscoff and choc ganache brownies, are popular at The Bakery Witch for sharing and gifting. Locals describe the presentation as beautiful and the treats as fresh, making them a handy pick-up for celebrations in Castle Hill.