Pie in the Sky Bakery

4.2(154)

Palm Court, shop 2, 3/176 The Entrance Rd, Erina, New South Wales, 2250

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersSourdough BreadTakeaway

Known for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Sausage rollsChicken mornay pieCurry pieTakeawayCoffeeWheelchair accessibleCard & contactless paymentsFree parking

Why Choose Pie in the Sky Bakery?

Pie in the Sky is the place locals travel to for proper pies, with a strong reputation for quality fillings and friendly service. Beyond the pies, they offer sourdough bread and take custom cake orders, plus free parking and wheelchair access make a visit easy.

About Pie in the Sky Bakery

Pie in the Sky Bakery in Erina is the kind of place people travel to when they want a proper pie, and the pies are clearly the main event. One customer celebrates family birthday occasions with the chicken mornay, along with other pies including the cheese and bacon, the mushroom and beef, and the curry pie. The cheese and bacon sausage roll has won over at least one self-confessed pie person, and the lamingtons get a mention too.

Beyond the pie warmer, the bakery turns out sourdough bread and takes custom cake orders. They also cater for personal and corporate events, so it's worth asking about if you have a function coming up. Takeaway is the way most people use it, and coffee is available if you want something to go with your pie.

One local says they often call in near closing time and get a couple of extra sausage rolls or quiches tossed in for the teenagers. Another travels to Erina specifically for the family pies. We've heard a grumble or two about pie prices, and one visit that didn't go smoothly at the counter, so it's wise to check the price before you pay.

The practical side is easy. There's a free car park, and both the car park and the entrance are wheelchair accessible. They take cards and tap-and-go mobile payments. Selection thins out late in the day, so go earlier if you have your heart set on a particular pie. Hours differ across the week, with a shorter day on weekends, so check before you set off.

If you're after a pie in Erina, this is a bakery worth putting on the list.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Service

“We regularly come here to grab some pies for dinner on nights we don't want to cook. The pies are delicious and good quality. The service is warm and very friendly.”

Pastries

“Absolutely delighted by the cheese and bacon sausage roll at Pie in the Sky Erina! I'm usually a pie person, but this sausage roll changed the game for me.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Pie in the Sky Bakery? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pie in the Sky Bakery

: This Erina bakery is best known for its pies, especially the chicken mornay, cheese and bacon, mushroom and beef, and curry pie. The cheese and bacon sausage roll is also a favourite, along with sweet treats like lamingtons and caramel slice. Families regularly choose the chicken mornay pie for birthday celebrations, and people travel from outside Erina just to stock up.
: Yes. Alongside its pie warmer favourites, Pie in the Sky Bakery bakes sourdough bread and takes custom cake orders. It's also set up for takeaway, so it's an easy stop for a quick lunch or to grab pies for dinner on a night off cooking.
: Most visitors describe the pies as good quality and reasonably priced for what you get, though a few have felt certain items like the standard meat pie run on the pricier side. It's worth asking staff about current pricing directly when you order, especially if you want extras like sauce.
: The bakery has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and car park, free on-site parking, and takes credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments. Coffee is also available alongside the pies and pastries, making it an easy stop for takeaway on the go.
: Many visitors mention warm, friendly service, with staff sometimes throwing in free sausage rolls for regulars near closing. That said, experiences can vary, so it's worth checking the hours before you head in to make sure you catch them at a good time.