Papa's Bagels

4.3(417)

569 Hunter St, Newcastle West, New South Wales, 2302

Papa's Bagels in Newcastle West
Services:Custom Cake OrdersDeliveryTakeawayDine-In
Fresh From the OvenFriendly Staff

Known for

BagelsBacon and egg bagelSweet bagelsTakeawayDeliveryDine-inCoffeeVegetarian options

Why Choose Papa's Bagels?

Papa's Bagels is valued locally for light, fluffy bagels loaded with flavour, from pastrami and bacon-and-egg to jalapeno with garlic cream cheese. The open-plan kitchen lets you watch the prep, the staff are genuinely welcoming, and coffee is a standout too.

About Papa's Bagels

Papa's Bagels is a bagel bar in Newcastle West that attracts visitors who stumble across it. The bagels come out fresh from the oven, and the people behind the counter are friendly. The kitchen is open-plan, so you can watch the dough being cut and prepped before it goes in.

Locals describe the bagels as light and fluffy rather than the dense, chewy New York style, which makes them easy to eat. The bacon and egg bagel is a popular choice, and a pastrami bagel with handmade pastrami and a decent serve of filling gets plenty of praise. Others rave about the jalapeno bagel with garlic and chive cream cheese, the Italian herbs and cheese one, and the salmon and cream cheese on an everything bagel. If you lean sweet, there's a blueberry bagel, and the caramelised onion bagel has its fans too. The tater tots on the side are worth adding. For a simple start, one first-timer called a butter and Vegemite bagel with everything seeds unexpectedly brilliant.

It's more than a bagel counter. Coffee gets a good word, with one local calling it some of the best in Newcastle, and the staff know their roast. You can dine in, with indoor and outdoor seating that suits kids, or take your order away. Delivery is available, online ordering covers pickup and pre-orders, and they do catering. There are vegetarian options on the menu, and the entrance is wheelchair accessible. Custom cake orders are also offered, so ask if you have an occasion coming up.

Papa's Bagels is open every day from early to mid-afternoon, which suits a breakfast, brunch or lunch stop, though it's smart to look up the hours. One person did say it's a little pricey, but they felt it was worth it. One visitor bought extras to freeze and take home, and a couple went two days running.

If you're looking for a bagel in Newcastle West, this one is easy to recommend, whether you're after a quick coffee and bagel on the way to work or a relaxed sit-down brunch.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“the bagels were so soft and fresh, the handmade pastrami was absolutely delicious and had the most perfect pepper flavour and they are not shy with the serving they give you!”

Staff

“The jalapeno bagel with garlic & chive cream cheese is divine, and the chilli one (pictured) was great too. Coffee is always on point. Friendly crew and the perfect pitstop on the way to the office.”

Pastries

“Unlike your traditional Montreal or New York bagels, these ones are light and fluffy. Easy to cut and won't be a chore to chow down on. Outstanding toppings.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Papa's Bagels? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa's Bagels

This bagel bar is known for bagels that come out light and fluffy rather than the dense, chewy New York style, making them easy to eat. Popular picks include the bacon and egg bagel, a handmade pastrami bagel, the jalapeno bagel with garlic and chive cream cheese, and sweet bagel options. The open-plan kitchen lets you watch the dough being cut and prepped before baking.

Yes. Alongside takeaway and delivery, Papa's Bagels has dine-in seating including outdoor seating, and serves coffee alongside breakfast, brunch, lunch and dessert options. It's wheelchair-accessible and good for kids, making it an easy stop whether you're grabbing a bagel on the run or settling in for a relaxed meal.

Papa's Bagels offers custom cake orders in addition to its bagel menu, plus catering for larger gatherings. For details on flavours, lead times and costs, it's best to contact the bakery directly since specifics can vary by order.

Yes, vegetarian options are available alongside the classic bagel fillings like bacon and egg. The menu covers sweet and savoury bagels, so there's a reasonable spread of choices beyond the meat-based options for anyone eating vegetarian.

The counter staff are consistently described as friendly and welcoming, with many visitors mentioning the lovely service they received even as first-time or passing-through customers. Combined with the fresh-from-the-oven bagels, this has helped make Papa's Bagels a well-regarded stop for people exploring Newcastle West.

Contact Details

Address
569 Hunter St, Newcastle West, New South Wales, 2302

How Papa's Bagels Compares

in Newcastle West

Rated 4.3, below the Newcastle West average of 4.4
This biz
4.3
Average
4.4

More reviews than 80% of bakeries in Newcastle West

Fresh From the Oven: 1 of 1 in Newcastle West

Opening Hours

Monday
7am-3pm
Tuesday
7am-3pm
Wednesday
7am-3pm
Thursday
7am-3pm
Friday
7am-3pm
Saturday
7am-3pm
Sunday
7am-3pm

Business Details

Service Options
Takeaway, Delivery, Dine-in
Payment Methods
Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments

Is this your bakery?

Claim your listing to control what this page says.

Claim this listing

Other Bakeries in Newcastle West

Bakers Delight Marketown in Newcastle West

Bakers Delight Marketown

4.1(87)
Newcastle West, New South Wales
Takeaway
Friendly Staff
Daily Bakehouse in Newcastle West

Daily Bakehouse

4.1(31)
Newcastle West, New South Wales
Takeaway
Known for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Bok Bok Enterprises

5.0(1)
Newcastle West, New South Wales
Takeaway
Friendly Staff

One roux.d baker

No rating
Newcastle West, New South Wales
Takeaway

More Bakeries in New South Wales

Nearby Bakeries

Vo's Bakery in Newcastle

Vo's Bakery

4.7(87)
Newcastle, New South Wales
Takeaway
Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesGood Value
Newcastle French Bread House in Newcastle

Newcastle French Bread House

4.6(69)
Newcastle, New South Wales
TakeawayDine-In
Known for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff
Union St. Pastry in Wickham

Union St. Pastry

4.9(102)
Wickham, New South Wales
TakeawayDine-In
Good ValueFriendly Staff
Banh Mi 233 in Newcastle

Banh Mi 233

4.2(238)
Newcastle, New South Wales
DeliveryTakeawayDine-In
Good ValueFriendly Staff
Harry's Café de Wheels - Newcastle in Newcastle

Harry's Café de Wheels - Newcastle

4.3(801)
Newcastle, New South Wales
DeliveryTakeawayDine-In
Known for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff
Bakers Delight Junction Fair in The Junction

Bakers Delight Junction Fair

4.1(43)
The Junction, New South Wales
DeliveryTakeaway
Fresh From the OvenGood ValueFriendly Staff