Baked on the Bay

4.9(29)

Shop 5-6/121-131 High Central Rd, Macleay Island, Queensland, 4184

Google Maps

Services:TakeawayDine-In

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Pepper steak pieTakeawayWheelchair accessibleCard & contactless payments

Why Choose Baked on the Bay?

Baked on the Bay earns loyal custom on Macleay Island for fresh bread, pies and pastries made daily on site, with the pepper steak and curry pies drawing particular praise. The staff are friendly and welcoming, and prices are fair, making it a strong neighbourhood bakery, though arrive early if you want first pick of the bread.

About Baked on the Bay

Baked on the Bay is the bakery Macleay Island locals reach for when they want something fresh from the oven, and the pies are a drawcard. The pepper steak pie gets plenty of attention, with chunky steak and a good peppery kick, and we've heard a curry pie described as the greatest one going. Potato pie is on the cabinet too, for anyone after something different.

Bread is the other big draw. Locals will tell you it's the best on the island, with the small catch that it pays to get in early if you want your pick. Alongside the loaves you'll find sandwiches, lunch rolls, sausage rolls and hot pies, so it works as a sit-down or takeaway lunch stop as much as a bread run. There's an outdoor sitting area as well as dine-in space.

The sweet side holds its own. People rave about apricot scrolls with generous pieces of fruit, jam and cream buns, a doughnut that's properly filled with jam, and chocolate chip cookies that one local called the best ever.

Value gets a mention, and the staff are friendly and easy to deal with, which is part of why islanders and visitors alike keep going back. They take cards and mobile payments, and there's a wheelchair-accessible car park. One person felt the entrance footpath could do with an upgrade, so take a little care on the way in. If you're hoping to call in on a particular day, check the hours before you head over.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Staff

“It makes a real change to buy freshly baked (on the premises) goods. The staff have been really friendly too, making it even easier to go back for more!”

Bread

“Lots of chunky steak, peppery and half a point for mushrooms which were a nice addition.”

Bread

“Always fresh. Always delicious. Greatest curry pie ever.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Baked on the Bay? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Baked on the Bay

: This bakery is best known for its pies, especially the pepper steak pie with chunky steak and a solid peppery kick, and a curry pie that local regulars rate highly. There's also a potato pie for something different. Bread is another big drawcard, with many locals calling it the best on the island, so it pays to arrive early for the best choice.
: Baked on the Bay offers both dine-in and takeaway, with an outdoor seating area mentioned by visitors. Alongside pies, the cabinet features sandwiches, lunch rolls, sausage rolls, hot pies, cakes and pastries, making it an easy stop whether you're grabbing something quick or settling in for a bite on Macleay Island.
: Yes, locals consistently mention good prices alongside the quality of the pies, sausage rolls and cakes. Staff are regularly described as friendly, which combined with the fresh-from-the-oven bread and pastries makes it a popular everyday stop for both residents and visitors to the island.
: The bakery accepts credit and debit cards as well as NFC mobile payments, so tap-and-go is easy. There's also a wheelchair-accessible car park, making it straightforward for all customers to pop in for fresh bread, pies and pastries on Macleay Island.
: Beyond the popular pepper steak and curry pies, Baked on the Bay bakes fresh bread daily along with sandwiches, lunch rolls, sausage rolls, cakes and pastries. Scrolls with generous fruit pieces and chocolate chip cookies also get a mention from regulars, so it's worth browsing the full cabinet when you visit.