My Sugar Daddy

4.9(43)

Unit 5/16-26 Semaphore Rd, Semaphore, South Australia, 5019

Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersTakeawayDine-In

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesCustom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Butter chicken pieBaklava cakeBacon and egg rollCoffeeBreakfastCard & contactless paymentsFree parking

Why Choose My Sugar Daddy?

My Sugar Daddy stands apart in Semaphore with Mediterranean-inspired pastries and cakes made fresh on the premises, from butter chicken pies loaded with real chicken to honey-soaked baklava. Locals praise the generous portions, friendly service and fair prices, plus solid coffee and comfortable seating for breakfast or a sweet break.

About My Sugar Daddy

If you're after a bakery in Semaphore that isn't just another beachside cafe, My Sugar Daddy is the one locals keep pointing people towards. The food leans Mediterranean, with Turkish, Greek and Albanian touches, plus a Kiwi twist here and there, and a good chunk of it is made on the premises.

Pies are the thing to know about. The butter chicken pie gets the most talk, with real chunks of chicken rather than mince and a gravy people rate above plenty of restaurant versions. The bacon and egg rolls are another regular order, fresh and generously filled. Then there's the sweet cabinet: the baklava cake, soaked in honey and rose water, has its own following, and the Lebanese, Albanian and Greek sweets are hard to choose between. They also take custom cake orders.

It works for a sit-down as well as takeaway. The Mediterranean village breakfast spread is big enough to feed more than the two it's meant for, and the coffee gets a nod too, with locals saying it's the real thing and not warm milk with a hint of coffee. There's seating inside for a rainy day and outdoor tables when the weather plays along.

We hear the portions are generous and the prices fair, and the staff are friendly. Many people mention the family running the place. Street parking is free but time-limited, and there's a car park too. One local found the range a little limited, so it's worth checking the hours and what's on before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Cakes

“Their chicken sandwhich rolls are the best but not as good as their baklava cake. It was just oozing with honey and so moist with the rose water; ate it all up.”

Value

“The staff are always so lovely. The food is great value with their generous serving sizes.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with My Sugar Daddy? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About My Sugar Daddy

: My Sugar Daddy is known for its Mediterranean menu with Turkish, Greek and Albanian touches plus a Kiwi twist. The butter chicken pie is the standout, made with real chunks of chicken rather than mince, and the bacon and egg rolls are another popular order. The sweet cabinet, including baklava cake, also gets plenty of attention from locals.
: Yes, My Sugar Daddy offers custom cake orders alongside its regular bakery and cafe menu. It's worth contacting them directly to discuss design, flavour and lead time for a custom order, especially if you're after something like their popular baklava cake style.
: Both options are available. My Sugar Daddy offers dine-in seating as well as takeaway, and locals mention there's enough room inside to sit down even on a rainy day. It's a good spot for breakfast, coffee or a sweet treat whether you're staying or heading to the beach.
: Local word of mouth consistently points to generous serving sizes, good value and a welcoming team, often described as a family running the place. Dishes like the butter chicken pie, bacon and egg rolls and baklava cake are regularly praised, along with the coffee and breakfast options. It's considered a standout among the cafes around Semaphore.
: My Sugar Daddy offers free street parking and a free car park, though one visitor noted nearby parking can be limited to around an hour, so it suits a quick bite or takeaway run. It's best to check signage on arrival if you're planning to dine in.