Rolf's Pies

Pie lovers in Box Hill South tend to know Rolf's Pies on Middleborough Road, a pie shop with a homemade-style bent. Their own line is "quality homemade pies and pasties", and that matches what people say about the place: hearty fillings, fresh-from-the-oven pastry and a wide range to choose from.

The pies are the main event. There are classic meat pies, a Bushman's pie that one long-time regular orders without fail, and a vegetarian option or two. We've heard a cheesy broccoli and leek pie described as one of the best meat-free pies someone had ever eaten. Sausage rolls and quiches get plenty of love too, and you'll find savoury pies in individual and family sizes alongside sweeter ones. Not everyone agrees on every item. One local would like bigger sausage rolls, and another found a vegetable pie only so-so, so it can pay to ask what's good that day. There's also a pie of the week if you like to try something different.

Beyond pies and pasties, the cabinet runs to donuts, vanilla slices, custard tarts, muffins and other sweet treats. People mention the donuts with real enthusiasm, and the muffins are considered good value for kids. Coffee is on offer, though one local called the latte just OK, so you may come for the food rather than the cup.

If you're feeding a crowd, Rolf's does party-size catering and delivery, and takeaway is the norm. One local who phoned in a savoury platter for a family birthday found the ordering easy, the pick-up service excellent and everything clearly labelled in the packaging. The frozen pie range is handy for stocking the freezer and taking some home.

The staff come up again and again, described as friendly, quick even when the lunchtime rush hits, and generous with the odd extra treat. The shop is simple and no-frills, clean and well kept, with free parking and wheelchair-accessible parking and entrance. They take cards and tap-and-pay, and they're open seven days, with slightly shorter hours on the weekend. Check the hours before you head in.