Johnny Baker Downtown
46 Forest St, Castlemaine, Victoria, 3450
“Johnny Baker is not only quality it is passion.”

Known for
Why Choose Johnny Baker Downtown?
Johnny Baker Downtown is known for standout pies, the beef and burgundy, chicken and leek, and vegetarian options like cauliflower and lentil shepherd's pies all come with generous fillings and well-baked pastry. The pastry counter is equally impressive, stocked with flaky croissants, tarts, meringues and custom cakes, and the team delivers consistently friendly service. They're wheelchair-accessible with free parking and takeaway options, making them a reliable stop for proper baked goods in Castlemaine.
About Johnny Baker Downtown
Pies are what Johnny Baker Downtown is known for around Castlemaine. The beef and burgundy gets a lot of love, along with the chicken and leek, and there are vegetarian options such as cauliflower and lentil shepherd's pies for those who skip the meat. One visitor from Melbourne was surprised to find a gluten free beef pie here, which is a real rarity. The pastry is described as supportive and well baked, and the fillings come generous.
It's a proper bakery in the full sense. The display cabinet is full of pastries, quiches, lemon tarts, giant meringues and cakes, and there's an open kitchen where you can watch the baking happen. We've heard the croissants are worth the trip, especially the buttery plain one and an almond croissant dusted generously with sugar. The vanilla slice is on the big side, so consider sharing. Sausage rolls and sandwiches are on offer too, and coffee and breakfast round out the visit.
Cakes are a real strength. Custom orders are welcome for birthdays and special occasions, and one local who has ordered mixed berry tarts several times says the communication by email is good and they turn out beautiful. She travels from Bendigo for them. Vegan options are available as well.
The staff get plenty of friendly mentions, and the vibe is warm and welcoming. If you're after something quick for lunch, they'll sort you out, and there's both takeaway and dine-in. One visitor felt the service stretched when the counter got busy, so a little patience on a long weekend is wise. If you're taking food away and want it kept cold, say so clearly when you order.
Getting here is easy. There is free street parking and a free car park, with a wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance, and cards and tap payments are all accepted. They're open every day of the week, but check the hours before you head in.
Location
What Customers Say on Google
“taste the flacky buttery plain croissant and you'll travel to France immediately!”
“Hands down the best pies we have ever eaten!! I had a vegetarian Shepherd pie which was rich balanced and delicious and my partner had a sensational gluten free beef pie which is a real rarity, even coming from melbourne.”
“Their pastries are true masterpieces, beautifully crafted and incredibly tasty. Each bite is a delight, showcasing their dedication to quality and flavor.”
Source: Google Reviews
Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny Baker Downtown
This bakery is best known for its pies, especially the beef and burgundy and the chicken and leek. Vegetarian options like cauliflower and lentil shepherd's pie are popular too, and a gluten free beef pie is available, which surprised one visitor from Melbourne as a genuine rarity. The pastry is well baked and the fillings are generous.
Yes, Johnny Baker Downtown offers vegan options alongside its usual range, and vegetarian pies such as cauliflower and lentil shepherd's pie are a highlight for those skipping meat. The display cabinet also carries a broad mix of pastries, quiches, lemon tarts and giant meringues to suit different tastes.
Yes, custom cake orders are available, including mixed berry tarts ordered for birthdays and special occasions. One customer travelling from Bendigo praised the clear communication by email about orders and said the cakes consistently look and taste great.
Both options are offered. Many customers lean towards takeaway, though there is seating if you want to sit and eat in. The bakery also serves coffee and breakfast, and it has wheelchair-accessible entrance and car park along with free street and on-site parking.
Beyond its well-loved pies and sausage rolls, the display cabinet is stocked with pastries, quiches, lemon tarts, giant meringues and cakes, with an open kitchen visible in store. Croissants, including an almond version, and simple lunch items like egg and lettuce sandwiches are also on offer, along with coffee and breakfast.
Contact Details
- Phone
- +61 3 5470 5695
- Address
- 46 Forest St, Castlemaine, Victoria, 3450
How Johnny Baker Downtown Compares
in Castlemaine
More reviews than 88% of bakeries in Castlemaine
Custom Cakes: 1 of 2 in Castlemaine
Opening Hours
- Monday
- 7am-5pm
- Tuesday
- 7am-5pm
- Wednesday
- 7am-5pm
- Thursday
- 7am-5pm
- Friday
- 7am-5pm
- Saturday
- 7am-5pm
- Sunday
- 7am-5pm
Business Details
- Service Options
- Takeaway, In-store shopping
- Payment Methods
- Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments
Other Bakeries in Castlemaine

SPROUT Bakery

Wesley Hill Bakery - Grist

Johnny Baker Uptown

McShanag's Bakery

The Hot & Crusty Country Bakery

More Bakeries in Victoria
Nearby Bakeries

Cafe Maldon

Maldon Bakery

Malmsbury Bakery Café


Community Comments
No comments yet. Have you dealt with Johnny Baker Downtown? Be the first to leave a comment below.