Flinders Vanilla Slice

Ask around Cheltenham about vanilla slice and this is the name that tends to come up. Flinders Vanilla Slice does the classic well, with a custard layer so tall that one slice is plenty for two, and people regularly end up sharing it. We hear it isn't overly sweet, with the pastry, icing and cream in good balance and a creamy, fresh custard that doesn't taste eggy or floury.

The original isn't the only choice. Passionfruit is a favourite, and the pistachio has a following because it's made with real pistachios rather than just flavouring. Locals are already planning return trips for the chocolate, caramel and tiramisu versions. One regular did suggest the custard could be a touch shorter to make the slice a bit more economical, but most people find it good value for the size.

The rest of the cabinet gets plenty of love too. The profiteroles and cannoli have their own fans, and the jam donuts are mentioned warmly. Not everything gets the same praise, though. One local wasn't won over by the sausage roll, finding it too heavy on pastry and crumb, so vanilla slice and the sweet treats are the safer bet. They also make custom cakes if you have an occasion coming up.

It's the kind of cafe where the owner and staff leave an impression. People talk about friendly, warm service, and about being handed a little extra to try, like a cannoli or a free cake with an order. It's an unassuming spot, and one local said it's a shame it isn't on a busier strip, because the food deserves the foot traffic.

You can dine in with a coffee or take your slice away, and delivery is available if you'd rather stay home. There's free street parking and a free car park, plus a wheelchair-accessible entrance and car park. They take cards and tap-and-pay. Opening days are limited, so check the hours before you head over.