Carah's Cakes & Pies

4.3(367)

61/63 Keppel St, Bathurst, New South Wales, 2795

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersCateringTakeawayDine-In

Known for PiesCustom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

SandwichesSausage rollsBirthday cakeTakeawayDine-inCoffeeBreakfastWheelchair accessible

Why Choose Carah's Cakes & Pies?

Carah's is a Bathurst institution known for pies that keep locals coming back. The brisket and gravy pie is raved about for its generous meat and balanced gravy, while the curry beef and steak and mushroom varieties have devoted followers. Beyond pies, they offer custom cakes, fresh sandwiches, sausage rolls and coffee, with dine-in, takeaway and catering options available.

About Carah's Cakes & Pies

Carah's Cakes & Pies is a bakery in Bathurst, New South Wales, that has been trading since December 1992, and the pie cabinet is the main reason people keep walking through the door. Locals will tell you the pastry is cooked right and the fillings are generous. The brisket and gravy pie gets raved about, and the curry beef, steak and mushroom, and pepper steak pies all have their followers. People who've called in from out of town tend to leave wishing they lived closer.

Beyond pies, the counter runs to fresh sandwiches, sausage rolls, tarts and slices, with coffee and breakfast on offer too. It's open early, which suits the morning crowd, though it's smart to look up the hours. You can eat in or take it away, and the lunchtime rush moves along quickly even when the place is packed.

Custom cakes are the other big part of the trade. People who've ordered birthday cakes here, including at fairly short notice, describe them as delicious and well priced, and the front-of-house team gets plenty of credit for patience when a design changes a few times along the way. Catering is available as well, so it's a handy name to know if you're feeding a group.

The service gets a lot of warm mentions. Staff are friendly and helpful even when the shop is flat out, and prices are regularly described as fair for the quality. One person had a curt exchange at the counter during a rush, and another suggested the tables could do with a quicker wipe-down at peak times.

There's free street parking and a free car park, with a wheelchair-accessible car park, and cards and mobile payments are accepted. For a good pie or a custom cake order in Bathurst, this is a bakery locals keep coming back to.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“One of the single best pies I've ever had. Came back 2 days in a row just to get another try. Brisket and gravy pie, generous on meat and just the right amount of gravy.”

Value

“Great fresh sandwiches cakes,pies etc, lovely hot coffee all reasonably priced & service with a smile.”

Staff

“I couldn't rate Carah's more highly!! In particular Kerry who provides professional, courteous service even when it's extremely busy.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Carah's Cakes & Pies? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Carah's Cakes & Pies

: Carah's Cakes & Pies has built its name on its pie cabinet. The brisket and gravy pie is a standout, along with curry beef, steak and mushroom, pepper steak and brisket jalapeno and cheese. The pastry is consistently cooked well and the fillings are generous, which keeps both locals and travellers passing through Bathurst coming back.
: Yes, custom cake orders are a core service at Carah's Cakes & Pies. Customers have had birthday and celebration cakes made on short notice, including cupcakes ordered with only half a day's warning, with staff praised for being helpful and patient even when requests change. It's best to call ahead to discuss your design and timing.
: Both. Carah's Cakes & Pies in Bathurst offers dine-in and takeaway, plus catering. The space serves coffee and breakfast alongside its bakery counter of pies, sandwiches, sausage rolls, tarts and slices, and it has a wheelchair-accessible car park and free street and car parking nearby.
: Customers regularly describe the pies and cakes at Carah's Cakes & Pies as reasonably priced for the quality and generous servings on offer. Staff are consistently noted as friendly and helpful, even during busy lunch periods, which adds to the sense of good value alongside the food itself.
: Beyond its well-known pies, Carah's Cakes & Pies offers fresh sandwiches, sausage rolls, tarts including Portuguese tart and citrus tart, slices, custom cakes, coffee and breakfast. It's a popular stop for a quick bite or a sit-down coffee in Bathurst, with table service available during busy periods.