Rustys Pies and Cakes

4.7(28)

136B Wyong Rd, Killarney Vale, New South Wales, 2261

Call Now Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersTakeaway

Known for PiesCustom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Birthday cakeQuicheSpecial occasion cakesTakeawayCard & contactless payments

Why Choose Rustys Pies and Cakes?

Known locally for quality pies and custom cakes at fair prices, with genuinely friendly service. Order a cake over the phone or drop in for pies, quiches and pastries; Vanessa handles special occasion cakes with care and attention to detail.

About Rustys Pies and Cakes

If you're after a bakery in Killarney Vale that does proper pies and a decent cake, Rusty's Pies and Cakes is where locals go. It's a small, friendly shop, and the pies are a big part of the appeal. We've heard the chicken boscaiola gets singled out for being moist rather than dry, and the chicken and asparagus has its fans too. Pasties and quiches turn up in the praise as well, with one visitor calling the pastie the tastiest they'd ever had.

Cakes are the other half of the story. Rusty's is a first choice for birthday and special occasion cakes, and they take custom orders. People talk about a passion fruit sponge made for an 80th birthday, lemon cupcakes made with extra lemon and rind to suit someone who doesn't like things too sweet, and a lamington cake that one local urges newcomers to order. Butter cakes are said to be a speciality, and Vanessa is named as the person who makes ordering easy, helpful and cheerful over the phone. The custard tart gets a nod too, for its jiggle and well-baked base.

Value comes up often. Locals describe the prices as fair and well below what you'd expect, and the staff are consistently called kind and approachable. One family felt a decoration didn't match what they'd asked for, so it pays to be clear about the details when you order.

Takeaway is the way to go, and they take card and tap payments. The hours are limited and the shop is closed some days, so check before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“The chicken boscaiola pie was so delish - not dry which I love about in my pies.”

Cakes

“Vanessa is absolutely fantastic when it comes to birthday cakes. She makes the best cakes for all occasions. Butter cakes are there speciality.”

Value

“The prices are so good and the quality and presentation of the cakes is amazing.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Rustys Pies and Cakes? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rustys Pies and Cakes

: Rustys Pies and Cakes is known for proper pies and custom cakes. The chicken boscaiola pie is a standout for being moist rather than dry, and the chicken and asparagus pie also has fans. Pasties and quiches are praised too, with one visitor calling the pastie the tastiest they'd ever had. It's a small, friendly shop that locals keep coming back to.
: Yes, custom cake orders are a core part of what Rustys Pies and Cakes does. Birthday cakes, special occasion cakes and even photo cakes are made to order, including for large events like anniversary dinners. Butter cakes, lamington cake and passionfruit sponge all get singled out as favourites, and the team is noted for being helpful and approachable when discussing requests.
: Yes, Rustys Pies and Cakes is set up for takeaway, making it an easy stop for a quick pie, quiche or pastie on the go. It accepts credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments, so you can grab something without needing cash. It's a popular pick for locals and for visitors passing through on their way to The Entrance.
: Many visitors describe Rustys Pies and Cakes as good value, with comments on fair pricing alongside solid quality. The steak, cheese and bacon pie gets praised for its pastry, while the custard tart and bacon quiche are also called out as standouts. For current pricing on pies, cakes or custom orders, it's best to ask the bakery directly.
: Yes, alongside its pies and cakes, Rustys Pies and Cakes gets strong mentions for its custard tart, described as having a perfect jiggle and a good baked base, and its quiches, including a bacon quiche praised as some of the best tasted outside of France. The scalloped pastry crust on the quiches is another detail visitors point to.