Better Batter Matters
Newcastle, New South Wales
“Made With Love.”
Why Choose Better Batter Matters?
Better Batter Matters handles custom cakes for all dietary needs, vegan, gluten-free, nut-free and others, and the cakes consistently impress guests who didn't expect them to taste this good. Prishila's approach to communication and care makes the ordering process straightforward, and locals return for birthdays, weddings and celebrations because the results are genuinely delicious.
About Better Batter Matters
Better Batter Matters is a home bakery in Newcastle, New South Wales, and it's a name locals pass along when someone needs a cake that works for everyone at the table. It's a women-owned business, and everything is made to order from scratch, with vegan, gluten-free and eggless cakes and desserts the whole focus.
Prishila, the baker, has spent 10 years perfecting her vegan and gluten-free recipes, and it shows. People who've ordered tell us the gluten-free cakes taste nothing like the usual compromise, and non-vegan family and friends have been caught going back for seconds. One coeliac customer said she'd never found a place making proper celebration cakes since her diagnosis, until now.
Custom cakes are the real strength here. We've heard of tiered wedding cakes, birthday cakes and wedding cupcakes made around a mix of dietary needs, including low sugar, nut allergies, gluten-free and vegan all at once. Prishila is known for clear, friendly communication from the first message to pickup, and one customer mentioned detailed tips on getting a cake to the venue in one piece. Her snack packs have been in demand too. Takeaway pickup is how it works, and locals consider it good value for the care that goes into each order.
Organic or sugar-free options are available at additional cost. The bakery is only open a few days a week, so check the hours and get your order in ahead of time rather than turning up on the day.
Location
What Customers Say on Google
“I could not recommend Better Batter Matters more, Prishila is extremely lovely to talk to and the communication and ordering process was clear, kind and concise.”
“The cake itself was for my Husbands birthday and was a massive hit getting rave reviews from everyone, especially us.”
“the price was very fair, and she even threw in for free some vegan friendly meringues she had made.”
Source: Google Reviews
Frequently Asked Questions About Better Batter Matters
Yes, vegan and gluten-free cakes are the main focus at Better Batter Matters. Baker Prishila makes everything to order from scratch, including eggless options, and coeliac customers have praised cakes that taste like the real thing rather than a compromise. Custom wedding cakes, birthday cakes and cupcakes can all be made to suit dietary needs like nut allergies or low sugar.
Custom cake orders are a specialty here, covering everything from multi-tiered wedding cakes to birthday cakes and cupcakes for events with mixed dietary needs. Customers in Newcastle highlight Prishila's clear communication, flexibility with design ideas and willingness to help with transport tips for tiered cakes, right through to last-minute emergency orders.
Alongside custom occasion cakes like vanilla, red velvet and carrot cake, the published menu includes cupcakes such as Vegan Oreo, Chocolate, Biscoff and Red Velvet, plus muffins including Lemon and Poppy Seed, Blueberry and Coffee and Chocolate. Everyday cakes on offer include Ginger Loaf, Orange and Date Cake, Banana Cake, Death by Chocolate and Lamingtons.
Yes, Better Batter Matters is a women-owned home bakery run out of a backyard studio in Newcastle, New South Wales. It's known locally for good value, friendly service and custom cakes made from scratch, with baker Prishila handling orders directly and guiding customers through the whole process from design to pickup.
Orders are arranged directly with Prishila, who locals describe as responsive and accommodating with pick-up times and custom requests. Since pricing depends on the cake, flavour and design, it's best to contact Better Batter Matters directly to discuss your requirements and get a quote before your event.
Contact Details
- Address
- Newcastle, New South Wales
How Better Batter Matters Compares
in Newcastle
46 reviews on Google
Custom Cakes: 1 of 1 in Newcastle
Opening Hours
- Monday
- Closed
- Tuesday
- Closed
- Wednesday
- 11am-3pm, 6-7pm
- Thursday
- 11am-3pm, 6-7pm
- Friday
- 11am-3pm, 6-7pm
- Saturday
- Closed
- Sunday
- Closed
Other Bakeries in Newcastle
Newcastle French Bread House
Harry's Café de Wheels - Newcastle
More Bakeries in New South Wales
Nearby Bakeries
Vietnam Nom Nom Bakery
Bakers Delight Junction Fair
DoughHeads
The Little French Cafe
Community Comments
No comments yet. Have you dealt with Better Batter Matters? Be the first to leave a comment below.