Bagel Bakery Cafe

4.4(136)

5/1 Caroline Chisholm Dr, Winston Hills, New South Wales, 2153

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersGluten-Free OptionsCateringTakeawayDine-In

Known for PiesCustom CakesFriendly Staff

Known for

LamingtonsSausage rollsCustomised cakeTakeawayDine-inCoffeeBreakfastWheelchair accessible

Why Choose Bagel Bakery Cafe?

Bagel Bakery Cafe in Winston Hills is known for generously filled pies with crisp pastry, custom cakes that impress at celebrations, and friendly service across the counter. With takeaway, dine-in, and catering options, plus accessibility features and free parking, it's a reliable local spot for breakfast, coffee or a cake order for a special occasion.

About Bagel Bakery Cafe

Bagel Bakery Cafe is a bakery in Winston Hills, New South Wales, that locals know for its pies, custom cakes and a counter crew who are friendly with it. It's a dine-in and takeaway spot, so you can sit down with a coffee and breakfast or grab a box and go.

The pies get a lot of mentions, with generous fillings and crisp pastry, and the sausage rolls are described as nice and flaky. Lamingtons are another favourite, particularly the jam and cream version, and people also rave about chocolate eclairs, apple cinnamon slice, quiche, cream buns and ham and cheese croissants. For celebrations, the custom cakes are the draw. One local ordered a Black Forest cake and called it amazing, and another family has ordered twice for birthdays and got plenty of compliments at their daughter's party, with a tip to have a chat with Stanley about the details.

Not every visit lands perfectly. We've heard the odd grumble about a pastry that was a bit firm or a pie that wasn't heated through, and one longtime regular felt the range of fresh items had thinned out lately. Still, some people come away happy.

They also do catering and gluten-free options, with the cafe side serving coffee and breakfast. Getting there is easy, with free street parking and a free car park, plus accessible parking and entry. Check the hours before you head in, especially for weekends.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“Great local bakery - pies were generously filled with a crisp pastry. Quiches was well seasoned and creamy, not too eggy.”

Cakes

“The customised cakes from here are fantastic. We have ordered twice from here and have been very impressed. They taste and look amazing!”

Value

“Really nice little bakery I stopped by today, coffee is awesome, sausage rolls are nice and flaky, the apple cinnamon slice was delicious too! Really good pricing as well.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Bagel Bakery Cafe? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bagel Bakery Cafe

: This Winston Hills bakery is well regarded locally for its pies, which come generously filled with crisp pastry, along with sausage rolls that are flaky, and lamingtons, especially the jam and cream version. Custom cakes are another favourite, often ordered for birthdays and special occasions, alongside quiches, cream buns and apple cinnamon slice.
: Yes, custom cake orders are one of the things this Winston Hills bakery is known for. Locals mention ordering customised cakes, including a Black Forest cake and a themed birthday cake, for events like children's birthdays, with Stanley often named as the one making them. It's worth discussing design and flavour details directly with the bakery.
: Yes, gluten-free options are listed among the services at this Winston Hills bakery, alongside catering, dine-in and takeaway. It's best to check with the bakery directly on which gluten-free items are available on a given day.
: Yes, Bagel Bakery Cafe in Winston Hills offers dine-in as well as takeaway, with coffee and breakfast available. It has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and car park, plus free street parking, making it an easy stop for a relaxed breakfast or a quick grab-and-go visit.
: Beyond its well-known pies, customers order chocolate eclairs, ham and cheese croissants, apple turnovers, custard tarts and bread. Lamingtons are a standout, with the jam and cream version frequently praised, and custom cakes such as Black Forest and tiramisu style cakes are also popular for takeaway or special occasions.