Pestka's Bakery

4.4(82)

17 Dawson St, Strathalbyn, South Australia, 5255

Call Now Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersTakeawayDine-In

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

DonutsPastiesVanilla sliceTakeawayCoffeeCard & contactless paymentsFree parking

Why Choose Pestka's Bakery?

Pestka's is known locally for pies that keep customers coming back, beef, pepper and potato, and cheeseburger varieties all get strong praise. The bakery bakes on site, so the bread, pastries and sweet treats are consistently fresh, and staff are genuinely friendly. It's also good value for money, with plenty of free parking and card payments available.

About Pestka's Bakery

If you're after a bakery in Strathalbyn that still does its baking on site, Pestka's Bakery is a friendly little place worth knowing about. It's a small shop in an older-style building, with a few tables for eating in and plenty of takeaway trade, and locals tend to describe it as cosy and welcoming rather than trendy.

Pies are what people talk about most. Pepper and potato, beef and a cheeseburger pie all get a mention, and the pasties and sausage rolls have their fans too. On the sweet side, the vanilla slice has people coming back for more, along with iced donuts, London buns and a honey stick that one local says actually tastes of honey. We've also heard the wholemeal loaves and rolls are good and fairly priced, and the ham and cheese loaves have a following. One thing to know: the sweet buns are filled with mock cream rather than fresh.

Opinion on the coffee and the donut dough is a little mixed, though the icing gets plenty of praise. Staff come across as cheerful and patient, even when you take your time choosing, and it's the sort of place people call in to again and again on the way through town. Cards and mobile payments are accepted, and there's free street parking nearby.

They're open weekdays and closed on weekends, so check the hours before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“Wholemeal bread loaves and rolls are amazing and well priced.”

Pastries

“Best pies I have ever had at Pestkas bakery ever! Very nice staff beef pies are my favourites!”

Value

“The lady who served us was just lovely and it would be one of the most affordable bakeries I've been to in years.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Pestka's Bakery? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pestka's Bakery

: Pestka's Bakery is known for its pies, with pepper and potato, beef and cheeseburger pie all popular among locals. It's a small, cosy shop in an older-style building that bakes everything on site, so pastries and bread come out fresh. Pasties and sausage rolls also have a following, and it's well regarded for friendly service and good value.
: Yes, the vanilla slice is a standout and gets repeat mentions, along with iced donuts, London buns and honey sticks. Note that sweet buns are made with mock cream rather than fresh cream. Cakes and cookies are also popular for morning tea orders, with several people praising them as soft and delicious.
: Yes, there's a small dine-in area with a few tables alongside plenty of takeaway trade. It's described as basic but cosy and welcoming rather than trendy. Coffee is available too, though it's been noted as less of a highlight than the food. Takeaway remains the main way most people order here.
: Yes, custom cake orders are offered alongside the everyday range of pies, pastries and sweets. The bakery has also supplied cakes and buns for work morning teas, with reports of colleagues being impressed by how soft and tasty they were. For specific custom cake details or pricing, it's best to ask the bakery directly.
: Pestka's Bakery accepts credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments, plus cash, and there's free street parking nearby. Some earlier visitors noted card facilities weren't always available, but this has since been addressed. It's a handy, no-fuss stop for a quick bite or a sit-down morning tea in Strathalbyn.