Miss Penny Cakes

4.8(176)

216-218 Melville Rd, Brunswick West, Victoria, 3055

“Finest Cake Specialist in Melbourne”

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersGluten-Free OptionsVegan OptionsCateringDeliveryTakeawayDine-In

Custom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

SpanakopitaCustard puddingSpecial occasion cakesTakeawayDeliveryIn-store pick-upCoffeeBreakfast

Why Choose Miss Penny Cakes?

Miss Penny Cakes delivers custom cakes that are genuinely beautiful and delicious, with the owner known for careful attention to detail and genuine warmth toward every customer. The café also stocks Greek pastries and excellent coffee, making it a solid neighbourhood stop for anything sweet or savoury.

About Miss Penny Cakes

Miss Penny Cakes is a cake specialist and café in Brunswick West, and it has been going for 4 years. Because cakes are its main trade, it sits at the edge of what this directory covers, but it is also a proper neighbourhood café with Greek pastries on the counter, so it earns its place for anyone after something sweet or savoury in Brunswick West.

The cakes are what most people come for. Locals who've ordered for birthdays, a baby shower and even a 60th describe cakes that look like works of art and taste just as good, with fresh flowers, hand-sculpted toppers and rich chocolate ganache among the details people remember. Penny gets credit for working from a loose brief or a single photo, and for being easy to deal with. One parent asked for dairy-free frosting because of an allergy and it was sorted without fuss. Gluten-free and vegan options are available, and custom orders, catering, takeaway and delivery are all part of the offer.

Then there's the café side. We hear the coffee is among the best in the area, and the counter is known for spanakopita, baklava, custard pudding and rice pudding, plus breakfast and lunches to eat in or take away. Staff are friendly, the place has a warm, community feel, and it's the kind of café people call their regular. It identifies as women-owned, and there's free street parking nearby, which helps on a busy morning.

A fair word of warning: it's popular, so it can get cramped if you're eating in, and the wait stretches a little on weekends. One visitor was unhappy with a box of cupcakes, but that's an outlier against the praise. Prices are considered good value.

Check the hours before you head in, as the bakery closes one day a week. For a special occasion cake, get in touch ahead of time so there's room to talk through your design.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Cakes

“Beautiful Penny did an amazing job on my daughter's 16th birthday cakes. Very professional and stress free to organise. The detail was with much care and accurately actioned in detail and of high quality ingredients, made an absolute stunning vanilla and strawberry flavoured cakes.”

Staff

“This is my go to cafe. Lovely staff. This is a family owned business and you can see how warm they are with the community.”

Cakes

“As always, the cakes are amazing. Penny has been fantastic everytime we've ever ordered. Both beautiful AND delicious.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Miss Penny Cakes? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Miss Penny Cakes

: Miss Penny Cakes is best known for custom celebration cakes, from birthdays to baby showers and milestone 60ths. People regularly mention hand-sculpted toppers, fresh flowers and rich mud or vanilla strawberry marble cakes that taste as good as they look. It also runs as a neighbourhood café, serving coffee, breakfast and Greek pastries like spanakopita alongside the cake counter.
: Yes, gluten-free and vegan options are available, and the team has accommodated requests like dairy-free frosting for allergy concerns. It's worth discussing your specific requirements directly with Miss Penny Cakes when placing a custom order so the cake can be tailored to suit.
: Beyond custom cakes, Miss Penny Cakes operates as a proper café with dine-in, takeaway and delivery. Coffee and breakfast are popular, and the counter features Greek treats such as spanakopita and custard pudding. Catering is also offered for events, making it a spot for both an everyday coffee and a special-occasion cake order.
: Many locals describe Miss Penny Cakes as good value considering the detail and quality of ingredients that go into each custom cake. Staff are regularly described as friendly and the owner is often noted as personally involved in serving customers. For current pricing on cakes or catering, it's best to contact Miss Penny Cakes directly.
: Given how popular the custom cake service is at Miss Penny Cakes, with orders for birthdays, baby showers and other celebrations, it's a good idea to get in touch well ahead of your date to discuss design and flavour details. The café itself can also get busy on weekends, so checking the hours before visiting for dine-in is worthwhile.