Haymisha Bakery

4.2(179)

320 Carlisle St, Balaclava, Victoria, 3183

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersDeliveryTakeaway

Custom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

CookiesBagelsChallahTakeawayIn-store pick-upCard & contactless paymentsFree parking

Why Choose Haymisha Bakery?

Haymisha is a highly rated kosher bakery that draws customers from across Melbourne for its wide range of breads, bagels, cakes and European-style pastries at good value. Known for custom cake orders and catering, with friendly service, delivery and free parking on hand.

About Haymisha Bakery

Haymisha Bakery is a kosher bakery in Balaclava, Melbourne, and it draws people from well beyond the neighbourhood. One local mentioned driving half an hour to get there and said it was worth it, which tells you something about the pull of a good kosher counter.

The range is wide. Breads, rolls and challah sit alongside strudels, pies, savouries, cookies, cupcakes and decorated cakes, plus dairy products, platters and miniatures. People talk fondly of the bagels, the poppyseed pastries, the sweet challah, lamingtons and vanilla slices. We've heard the chocolate babka and the knishes are big favourites, and one regular loves the sausage rolls filled with potato instead of meat. Cakes are clearly the main event. One local said the cakes might not look fancy, but they taste amazing.

Custom cake orders and catering come up often. A Black Forest cake and dessert platters went down well at one event, and a birthday cake was a hit with a whole family. Orders can go through the website, and it's worth allowing a couple of business days' notice. They also offer takeaway and delivery, and in-store shopping and pick-up work too. There's free street parking nearby, and they take cards and mobile payments.

Locals describe the prices as fair for what you get, and the staff as obliging and genuinely interested in their customers. One visitor had a poor experience with counter service and hygiene, so the odd grumble is out there, but most people leave happy.

The opening hours follow the Jewish calendar and the bakery isn't open on weekends, so check the hours before you head in, especially around holidays. For kosher bread, cakes or a catering order in Balaclava, it's a familiar name among locals.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Value

“I drove 30 min to get to this bakery but it was worth it.”

Pastries

“Their chocolate babka is an absolute hit; so are the knishes.”

Staff

“Haymisha Bakery truly offers the best food paired with exceptional customer service.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Haymisha Bakery? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Haymisha Bakery

: Haymisha Bakery is a kosher bakery known for its breads, rolls and challah, along with strudels, pies, savouries, cookies, cupcakes and decorated cakes. Regulars particularly rate the bagels, poppyseed pastries, sweet challah, lamingtons, vanilla slices, chocolate babka and knishes. Dairy products, platters and miniatures round out the range, drawing people from well beyond the local area.
: Yes, custom cake orders are a core part of what Haymisha Bakery offers. People have ordered cakes for birthdays and catered events, with several mentioning a Black Forest cake and dessert platters that went down well at functions. One customer also notes cakes made mehadrin kosher and Yoshon even during Chodosh season, so it's worth asking about specific kosher requirements when ordering.
: Many regulars describe Haymisha Bakery as good value, pointing to moderately priced kosher breads, pastries and cakes. A few mention driving well out of their way because the quality justifies the trip. For current pricing on breads, cakes or custom orders, it's best to ask the bakery directly.
: Haymisha Bakery offers takeaway, in-store pick-up and in-store shopping, along with delivery for those who can't get there in person. It accepts credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments, and there's free street parking nearby in Balaclava, which makes a quick bread or pastry run easy.
: Most locals describe the staff as obliging and taking a personal interest in orders, with many calling out the quality and consistency of the products as reasons they keep coming back. A smaller number of locals mention less satisfying service experiences, so as with any busy bakery, it can vary. Since hours can shift around Jewish holidays, it's worth checking before visiting.