Keith Home Made Cakes

4.3(99)

46 Church St, Brighton, Victoria, 3186

“The shop of quality”

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Custom Cake OrdersCateringDeliveryTakeaway

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesCustom CakesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Sausage rollsPastiesTraditional meat piesTakeawayDeliveryIn-store pick-upCoffeeWheelchair accessible

Why Choose Keith Home Made Cakes?

Keith Home Made Cakes delivers on both sides of its trade: the pies and savouries (chicken and leek, sausage rolls, spinach rolls and pasties) come hot and fresh, while the cakes, from carrot to custom orders, are handmade with care. They handle last-minute cake requests well and offer delivery and catering, making them a solid local choice for either a quick savoury lunch or a special order.

About Keith Home Made Cakes

Keith Home Made Cakes is a Middle Brighton shop that does a good deal more than its name suggests. Pies and savouries sit right alongside the cakes, and "the shop of quality" is how they put it themselves. It works as a walk-in store and takeaway for the Brighton community, and they also do delivery, in-store pick-up and catering.

The pies are what people tend to bring up first. Locals rave about the chicken and leek, there are traditional meat pies, and sausage rolls, pasties, spinach rolls and a veggie pastie keep turning up in conversation too. Items come out hot and fresh from the oven, with sandwiches, curry puffs, biscuits and slices in the cabinet for a quick lunch. We hear the prices feel fair for what you get, and you can grab a coffee while you're there.

Custom cakes are a big part of the trade. One local was thrilled when the team turned around a first birthday cake at very short notice, and the staff are often described as friendly and helpful, both in store and on the phone. Opinion on the baking itself is a little mixed: some people rave about the carrot cake and the sweets, while a few have found the sponges or a pie below par and the service a bit patchy on some visits.

If you're ordering a celebration cake or a party box, ring ahead and check the opening hours before you head in. There's a wheelchair-accessible car park, and cards and mobile payments are accepted.

Location

Slice Box
$17.50
Keith Selection
$19.80
Apple Strudel
$22
Mini Gingerbread
$16.50
Mini Cupcakes
$16.50
Regular Gingerbread Man
$4.20
Party Box
$27.50
Carrot Muffin
$6
Plain Lamington
$5.70
Health Cake
$6
Apple Slice
$5.70
Vanilla Slice
$5.70
Passionfruit Puff
$6
Butterfly Cream Cake
$6
Cream & Jam Lamington
$6
Chocolate Éclair
$6
French Vanilla Slice
$6
Fruit Tart
$6
Mixed Biscuit
$18.90
Macaron Pack 6 Pcs
$18

Daily Cake Range

Strawberry Gateau
$48.90
Nougat Sponge
$48.50
Small Chocolate Mud
$45.50
Tiramisu Mousse
$33
Chocolate Mousse
$33
Passionfruit Cream Sponge
$19
Dusted Cream Sponge
$19
Chocolate Cream Sponge
$19

Savouries

Cauliflower & Cheese Pie
$8.20
Beef & Mushroom Pie
$7.50
Regular Spinach Quiche
$7
Regular Bacon Quiche
$7
Spinach & Ricotta Rolls
$4.20
Regular Sausage Rolls
$4.20
Party Pies
Each or Dozen
$2.50
Vegetable Pastie
$7.50
Beef & Vegetable Pastie
$7.50
Chicken & Vegetable Pie
$8.20
Beef & Onion Pie
$7.50
Beef & Curry Pie
$7.50
Potato Top Pie
$7.50
Plain Beef Pie
$6.50

View full menu →

Menu as published at keithcakes.com.au on 28 October 2026. Prices change; confirm with the shop.

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“Chicken and leek pie has potato in it and its is so lovely!! I had a great coffee too. The service is wonderful and the people there gave the patience of saints!”

Cakes

“Good carrot cake is hard to find. At Keith Cakes it's hand-made to perfection. It's rich and moist and not oily and cuts well.”

Value

“Very reasonably priced and great for a quick lunch.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Keith Home Made Cakes? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Keith Home Made Cakes

: Keith Home Made Cakes in Middle Brighton is known for both its cakes and its savouries. Traditional meat pies, sausage rolls, pasties and spinach rolls come up often, with the chicken and leek pie a particular favourite. Alongside that, custom cakes, mini gingerbread, slices and daily cake options like tiramisu mousse and chocolate mud round out the range.
: Yes, custom cake orders are one of their core services. People have ordered birthday cakes, including last-minute requests, and the shop has managed quick turnarounds with decorated cakes and matching cupcakes. Catering and party boxes combining pies and desserts are also available for gatherings.
: Keith Home Made Cakes offers takeaway, delivery and in-store pick-up, so it suits a quick lunch stop or a pre-ordered pickup. The Brighton shop also has coffee on offer and a wheelchair-accessible car park, with payment by credit card, debit card or NFC mobile payment.
: Items are generally baked fresh from the oven, with hot pies, sausage rolls and pasties a regular pick for locals in Brighton. The savoury range includes beef and mushroom pie, cauliflower and cheese pie, spinach and bacon quiches, and spinach and ricotta rolls alongside the classic sausage roll.
: Several visitors have called the shop reasonably priced for a quick lunch, picking up hot savouries, sandwiches and a baked treat without paying a premium. For exact pricing on cakes, catering or custom orders, it is best to ask Keith Home Made Cakes directly when placing an order.