The Pie Tin

4.3(1190)

1a Brown St, Newtown, New South Wales, 2042

“Delicious sweet & savoury pies, handmade on premises”

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:DeliveryTakeawayDine-In

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

Savoury optionsSweet piesSavoury piesTakeawayDeliveryDine-inIn-store pick-upCoffee

Why Choose The Pie Tin?

The Pie Tin is known locally for handmade pies with consistently excellent pastry, flaky, crisp and well-crafted whether you're after savoury meat pies or sweet options. The savoury range draws particular praise for generous, tender fillings, whilst sausage rolls and sweet pies alike are made fresh on premises, and good-value slices and discounts keep it accessible for a quick visit or longer stay.

About The Pie Tin

If you're after a proper pie in Newtown, The Pie Tin is the sort of place people point you towards. It's a home-style pie shop that makes everything by hand on the premises, and the pastry is where it shows. We've heard it described as flaky and well cooked, with a thick, crisp crust on the fruit pies and sugar scattered across the top.

The savoury side gets plenty of love. One local rated the lamb and rosemary pie as the best they know, and others rave about the BBQ brisket and the steak and ale, with generous fillings and tender chunks of meat. The sausage rolls have their own following too. One visitor came in on the strength of an Instagram tip and left impressed that the filling wasn't padded out with breadcrumbs. It also comes with a proper tub of rich tomato sauce rather than little packets.

Then there's the sweet side, which is just as much the point here. Pumpkin pie is a favourite with regulars, and banana biscoff, sticky date pudding with butterscotch sauce, whipped lime and blueberry meringue all get a mention. There are tarts and cheesecakes in the cabinet as well, including a pistachio Basque cheesecake and a raspberry and lemon curd tart that one local called nicely tart and not overly sweet. One customer found the range wide enough that choosing a favourite was the hard part.

You can eat in, take away, have it delivered or pick up in store, and there's coffee and breakfast on offer too. Their pies are paired with fresh coffee from locally roasted beans and local craft beer. The staff come across as friendly, and the room has a calm feel with plenty of seats. One visitor was happy to find their dogs welcomed inside.

It can get busy at lunchtime on weekends, and popular items sell out, so go earlier if you have your heart set on something. Street parking nearby is free but can be tight. Prices are a touch above a standard bakery pie, though most people feel the quality justifies it. Check the hours before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Bread

“The meat pie was fresh with chunks of tender meat and a beautifully flaky crust.”

Pastries

“This place has the best lamb & rosemary meat pie I know... and I say that as someone who owned a hobby farm for 7 years and regularly ate home prepared lamb and rosemary.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with The Pie Tin? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Pie Tin

: The Pie Tin is a home-style pie shop in Newtown known for handmade pies baked fresh on the premises. Locals rate the lamb and rosemary pie highly, along with the BBQ brisket and steak and ale pies, which come with generous, tender fillings and flaky, crisp pastry. The sausage rolls and sweet pies like pumpkin and banana biscoff also have a strong following.
: Yes, alongside its savoury range The Pie Tin offers a good variety of sweet pies and desserts, including pumpkin pie, banana biscoff, blueberry meringue, sticky date pudding pie with butterscotch sauce, and cheesecake-style pies like pistachio basque. Tarts such as raspberry and lemon curd or chocolate and Earl grey also feature, alongside coffee and breakfast options.
: The Pie Tin offers dine-in, takeaway and delivery, plus in-store pick-up. The Newtown shop has a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere suited to sitting down with a coffee or grabbing something on the go. It also offers wheelchair-accessible entry and parking, free street parking, and accepts credit, debit and mobile payments.
: Customers consistently describe The Pie Tin as good value, with helpful staff and generous fillings in its savoury pies. The shop can sell out of popular items by lunchtime on busy days, so it pays to visit earlier if you have your heart set on a particular pie. Ask in-store about current pricing.
: The pastry is a highlight at The Pie Tin, often described as flaky, crisp and well cooked, with a thick, crisp crust especially noticeable on fruit pies like cherry and apple crumble. Everything is handmade on the premises in Newtown, which locals say shows in the quality and consistency of both the sweet and savoury ranges.