ButterBoy Byron Bay
17/21 Jonson St, Byron Bay, New South Wales, 2481
“The best cookies in Australia.”
Known for
Why Choose ButterBoy Byron Bay?
ButterBoy is a cookie specialist that bakes fresh daily in Byron Bay, turning out large, gooey cookies that are soft and chewy in the middle. The Bueno, cinnamon bun, and macadamia varieties all have devoted fans, and they offer vegan and gluten-free options, delivery and custom orders if needed.
About ButterBoy Byron Bay
ButterBoy is a cookie bakery in Byron Bay, and cookies are very much the whole point. They bake fresh daily, and locals will tell you the result is large, gooey and soft in the middle, often still slightly warm when it reaches you. The Bueno cookie gets mentioned more than any other, with the cinnamon bun, white choc macadamia and coconut macadamia close behind. One visitor put it simply: "The cookie and ice cream combination is a must."
There are vegan and gluten-free options if you're catering for different diets, plus custom orders, takeaway and delivery. The matcha drinks have their fans too, and one person called the strawberry matcha a nice surprise.
People generally find the cookies good value for the size and quality, though a few say they sit at the pricier end of a treat, so expect to pay a little more than a standard bakery biscuit. Staff can be inconsistent on a busy day, so patience helps.
Worth knowing before you go: it's a card-only shop, so bring a card or phone to pay rather than cash. The hours run into the evening most nights, which suits a late dessert stop, but check the times before you head in. If you're after a cookie fix in Byron Bay, this is the one people keep coming back to.
Location
What Customers Say on Google
“The cookies were so gooey, fresh and delicious! The perfect texture, soft and chewy in the middle with just the right amount of sweetness.”
“The Cinnamon Bun cookie with cream cheese icing is incredible, I had to go back for another before I leave Byron Bay. Also tried the Bueno cookie which was absolutely delicious. Baked to perfection, loaded and gooey inside, you won't be disappointed!”
Source: Google Reviews
Frequently Asked Questions About ButterBoy Byron Bay
ButterBoy is a cookie bakery in Byron Bay where cookies are the main event. They're baked fresh daily, large, gooey and soft in the middle, often still slightly warm. The Kinder Bueno flavour is the most talked-about, with cinnamon bun, white choc macadamia and coconut macadamia also popular. They're also known for their matcha drinks, including a strawberry matcha.
Yes, ButterBoy offers both vegan and gluten-free cookie options alongside their regular range, so it's worth asking in-store or checking their website if you're catering for different diets. Custom cake orders can also be arranged for special occasions.
ButterBoy offers takeaway and delivery, plus custom orders for cakes, making it easy to grab cookies on the go or arrange something ahead of time. Payment is by card or contactless only, cash isn't accepted, so bring a card or tap-and-go device when you visit.
Opinions on value vary, with some visitors calling the cookies a bit expensive while most agree they're worth it for the size and quality. The cookies are consistently described as fresh, large and gooey. For current pricing, it's best to ask the bakery directly or check their menu in-store.
Most visitors praise the cookies themselves as fresh and delicious, with the Bueno and cinnamon bun flavours getting particular mentions. Experiences with staff have been mixed, with some describing friendly service and others noting slower or less attentive moments at the counter, so patience during busy periods can help.
Contact Details
- Address
- 17/21 Jonson St, Byron Bay, New South Wales, 2481
How ButterBoy Byron Bay Compares
in Byron Bay
44 reviews on Google
Opening Hours
- Monday
- 9am-9pm
- Tuesday
- 9am-9pm
- Wednesday
- 9am-9pm
- Thursday
- 9am-9pm
- Friday
- 9am-10pm
- Saturday
- 9am-10pm
- Sunday
- 10am-9pm
Business Details
- Service Options
- Takeaway
- Payment Methods
- Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments
Other Bakeries in Byron Bay
Sunday Sustainable Bakery
Sunday Sustainable Bakery
Byron Bay Hotbread After Hours
Masa Byron Bay
Byron Hot Bread Daytime Bakery
More Bakeries in New South Wales
Nearby Bakeries
Nera Sweet Goods
Suffolk Bakery
Butcher Baker Bangalow
Bangalow Bread Co.
Uncle Tom's Pies
Community Comments
No comments yet. Have you dealt with ButterBoy Byron Bay? Be the first to leave a comment below.