Sydney Pie Cafe

3.8(121)

Capitol Square, Haymarket, New South Wales, 2000

Google Maps

Services:DeliveryTakeawayDine-In

Fresh From the OvenKnown for PiesGood ValueFriendly Staff

Known for

HotdogsSausage rollsChilli hotdogTakeawayDeliveryDine-inCoffeeBreakfast

Why Choose Sydney Pie Cafe?

Sydney Pie Cafe delivers proper pies with golden, flaky pastry and warm, well-seasoned fillings, the pepper steak and classic meat pie are standouts, plus sausage rolls and hotdogs that hold up well for takeaway. The casual diner atmosphere at Capitol Square draws locals for fair prices and quick, friendly service.

About Sydney Pie Cafe

If you're after a proper pie in Haymarket, Sydney Pie Cafe is a casual, diner-style spot just off George Street at Capitol Square, and it's built around exactly that. Pies are what it's known for, and locals say the pastry comes out golden and flaky with a warm, well-seasoned filling. The pepper steak gets mentioned most, alongside the classic meat pie, curry pie and a spinach and feta pastie served with mash, peas and gravy.

Beyond the pies, there are sausage rolls and hotdogs, including a chilli hotdog and a classic with cheese sauce that people say holds up well, with the bun staying soft even as takeaway. Roast beef rolls with gravy and chips with chicken salt come up too, and a custard tart and coffee make an easy way to finish. We've heard the food tastes freshly out of the oven and is fair value for this part of the city.

You can dine in, grab takeaway or have it delivered, and there's a coffee and breakfast offering as well. The entrance and seating are wheelchair accessible, cards and mobile payments are taken, and the place is LGBTQ+ friendly. It keeps long hours, with late nights towards the end of the week, which suits a post-show bite. One local wasn't happy with the hygiene at the counter, and another found the service a little hard to follow, but plenty describe the staff as friendly and quick. Check the hours before heading in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Pastries

“The pastry was golden and flaky, and the filling was warm and flavorful without being too heavy.”

Value

“Good pies at great prices (for Sydney).”

Service

“The service also very quick and friendly.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with Sydney Pie Cafe? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sydney Pie Cafe

: It's known for proper Aussie pies, served diner-style just off George Street at Capitol Square. The pepper steak pie gets the most mentions, along with the classic meat pie, curry pie and a spinach and feta pastie topped with mash, peas and gravy. Expect golden, flaky pastry and a warm, well-seasoned filling.
: Yes. Alongside its pies, Sydney Pie Cafe serves sausage rolls, hotdogs including a chilli hotdog, and a classic hotdog with cheese sauce on a soft bun. Coffee and breakfast are also on offer, making it a handy stop beyond just pie cravings.
: Sydney Pie Cafe offers dine-in, takeaway and delivery, so you can eat in at the Haymarket spot near Capitol Square or have your pie or hotdog brought to you. The venue also has wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating.
: Many visitors mention it as good value, with one regular calling it good pies at great prices for Sydney. Portions like the meat pie and spinach and feta pastie with mash, peas and gravy are often praised as satisfying for the price, though it's worth asking the cafe directly for current pricing.
: Service is generally described as friendly and quick, with staff praised for being polite even during busy periods near Capitol Square. A few visitors have noted the occasional slow moment, so it pays to go in patient, but most describe the experience as pleasant and efficient.